Showing posts with label TV. Show all posts
Showing posts with label TV. Show all posts

Saturday, January 17, 2009

Prime Time TV and Law School

Grey's Anatomy has a plot this week that includes a serial killer with brain tumors who wants to refuse treatment.  The doctors tell him that he can refuse to be operated on while he's conscious,  but once he passes out it only takes the consent of two doctors to overrule the patient's wishes and force treatment.  

Health Care lawyers out there: is this true?  When the patient has stated, with witnesses (and he's sane), that he doesn't want treatment, why would the hospital want to force expensive treatment on him?  Wouldn't that treatment best be saved for somebody who wants it, and somebody who society wants around (a non-serial killer)?

Despite the policy considerations of saving a serial killer, the Hippocratic Oath does command that doctors preserve life.  Do they have to preserve life against the patients' wishes?  Do the patients' wishes not matter anymore after they've passed out?